How Are Pressure Transducers Affected by Hydrogen Permeation?
You can find hydrogen in a wide range of industrial applications and processes just about everywhere these days. Hydrogen is one of the fastest-growing alternative energy resources used today. Some of its uses include:
- Petroleum refining – hydrocracking
- Fuel cells
- Hydrogen fueling stations
- Glass manufacturing
- Semiconductor manufacturing
- Aerospace applications
- Fertilizer and ammonia production
- Welding, annealing, and heat-treating metals
- Power plant generator cooling
- Hydrogenation of unsaturated fatty acids in vegetable oil
Many of these hydrogen applications have processes that can cause hydrogen ion diffusion. This can lead to hydrogen permeation and embrittlement, which can lead to the premature failure of your pressure transducer.
Pressure gauges, switches and sensors can all be used in hydrogen applications. In this article, I will focus on pressure sensing devices (referred to here as transducers), which convert applied pressure to an electrical signal to measure the pressure being applied in an application.
To ensure you have the best pressure transducer for a hydrogen application, there are a few things that you need to consider such as the wetted material of the diaphragm and pressure range of the application. As the pressure of an application increases, it adds stress to the diaphragm, which can help speed up the effect of hydrogen embrittlement.
Let’s take a look at permeation and embrittlement and the effects they can have on your pressure transducers.
Hydrogen permeation refers to the penetration of hydrogen ions through the lattice structure of a particular material. This can cause concerns in pressure transducers that rely on a thin metal diaphragm to translate the pressure either directly to a strain gauge or through a fluid-isolated sensor that attaches to a strain gauge.
In both instances, the diaphragm becomes the weak link in the system. Over time, permeation will cause signal drift or an outright failure if the correct wetted material is not selected for the application.
If transducers incorporate fluid-isolated sensors, hydrogen permeation can be an issue. Fluid-isolated sensors rely on a thin metal isolation diaphragm to keep hydrogen from permeating into the isolation fluid.
If hydrogen permeation occurs in this type of sensor, the hydrogen ions that permeate through the diaphragm material can reform in the isolation fluid as hydrogen molecules. The molecules will then collect and form a hydrogen bubble. These bubbles will cause a shift in the zero output of the transducer and can result in output drift over time.
One way to reduce hydrogen permeation is to use a material with a tight lattice structure such as 316L stainless steel or variants of 316 stainless steel. Another solution is to add a very thin layer of gold plating to the diaphragm. The gold layer has a very tight lattice structure that increases the diaphragm’s resistance to hydrogen permeation
In addition to the lattice structure of a material, hydrogen permeation is also influenced by the pressure of an application. The higher the pressure of the application, the larger the force that is applied to the diaphragm.
This force stretches the lattice structure of the material, allowing more hydrogen ions to permeate the material. Therefore, you should use a material that not only has a tight lattice structure but is well suited to handle the pressure range of the application.
Embrittlement is a phenomenon that causes loss of ductility and, consequently, brittleness in a material. Highly susceptible materials include high-strength steels, titanium and aluminum alloys, and electrolytic tough-pitch copper.
Hydrogen embrittlement is also known as hydrogen-induced cracking or hydrogen attack. The mechanisms can be aqueous or gaseous and involve the ingress of hydrogen into the metal, reducing its ductility and load-bearing capacity.
But what causes embrittlement?
Because hydrogen is such a small atom, it can penetrate the metal through micro flaws in the surface. Once inside, the hydrogen atoms will recombine with others to form hydrogen molecules (H2).
These molecules will bond with other H2 molecules resulting in a bigger hydrogen mass that exerts outward pressure on the flaw. Stress below the yield stress of the susceptible material then causes subsequent cracking and catastrophic brittle failures.
As hydrogen molecules defuse, they create hydrogen ions, which are some of the smallest ions in the world. They can pass through the lattice structure of many metals and into the metal, and then reform as hydrogen molecules.
The absorbed hydrogen molecules create pressure and stress from within the material. This can affect the ductility and strength of the material, ultimately leading to the material cracking.
NASA crews work with hydrogen often and have defined multiple types of hydrogen embrittlement:
- Hydrogen Embrittlement — A process resulting in a decrease in the fracture toughness or ductility of a metal due to the presence of atomic hydrogen.
- Hydrogen Environmental Embrittlement (HEE) — The degradation of certain mechanical properties that occur while a material is under the influence of an applied stress and intentionally exposed to gaseous hydrogen environment.
- HEE Index — An initial material screening tool to evaluate the severity of hydrogen embrittlement effects on certain materials.
- Internal Hydrogen Embrittlement (IHE) — The degradation of certain mechanical properties that occur as the result of the unintentional introduction of hydrogen into susceptible metals during forming or finishing operations.
- Hydrogen Reaction Embrittlement (HRE) — The degradation of certain mechanical properties that occur when hydrogen reacts with the metal matrix itself to form metallic compounds such as metal hydride at relatively low temperatures. This form of hydrogen damage can occur in materials such as titanium, zirconium, and even some types of iron or steel-based alloys.
We don’t like to pressure you, but we have more information
I hope this article helped shine a light on the dangers of hydrogen permeation and embrittlement. If you want to ensure safe hydrogen applications, use pressure transducers with at least 316L stainless steel and for pressure ranges 5,000 psi or greater A286 wetted diaphragm materials and avoid oil-filled sensors, which can create bubbles and sensor drift.
In hydrogen applications, Ashcroft recommends a material called A286 for pressure ranges over 5,000 psi. A286 maintains its tight lattice at pressures up to 20,000 psi, limiting hydrogen permeation (but it does not incorporate an isolation fluid).
If you want more information on how hydrogen systems affect pressure instrumentation, download our guide, "Hazards and Safe Operation of Pressure and Temperature Instruments in Hydrogen Systems."
We also have a few related blog articles that you may find helpful:
- How Much Do Pressure Transducers Cost? (6 Factors Impacting Price)
- How Does Media Temperature Affect Pressure Transducer Performance?
- Choosing the Right Pressure Sensor: 5 Factors to Consider
Or, contact us today to talk to one of our industry experts and get all of your questions answered.